Döbereiner identified groups of three elements with related properties. For several triads, the relative atomic mass of the middle element was close to the average of those at the two ends.
Newlands listed the known elements in increasing atomic weight and noticed a recurrence of similar properties at intervals of eight, counting the first element as one. The pattern worked best for lighter examples and failed as a general arrangement.
Mendeleev arranged elements broadly by atomic mass and grouped them by chemical similarities. He left spaces where the patterns suggested missing elements and used the surrounding entries to predict their properties.